SFD issues on the table

   #1  

icardiag

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Mar 30, 2014
Messages
119
Reaction score
106
Location
Europe
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=113031
Today I tried to unlock a SFD protected unit connected on the table, but I got "Online SFD requires a valid VIN". The original gateway & instrument cluster is in the car; on the table I have just the faulty MIB3 unit connected to a virgin gateway. Few weeks ago I had absolutely no issues unlocking a similar MIB3 unit on the table. Maybe something changed recently?
I understand the VCDS was unable to pull the VIN from the car, but the field for entering the VIN code is read-only and I can't enter the VIN code. Is it intentionally left read-only even when VIN code retrieval was not successful?
The SFD session was started as always, but this time I noticed a "Service status: Code 17" in the SFD manager. What does this code mean?
Thanks in advance!
 
   #2  

Uwe

Benevolent Dictator
Administrator
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
63,319
Reaction score
43,663
Location
USA
VCDS Serial number
HC100001
the field for entering the VIN code is read-only and I can't enter the VIN code. Is it intentionally left read-only even when VIN code retrieval was not successful?
Yes, I believe it is. Allowing people to enter an arbitrary VIN opens the potential for certain cheating of the system and we really do not wish to have a falling out with VW.

Maybe something changed recently?
Not that I am aware of.

this time I noticed a "Service status: Code 17" in the SFD manager.
I believe this means you are eligible to renew your SFD subscription, but the current VCDS doesn't know how to tell you that yet. Right now, you are still using your free Beta service from 2026-05-13, which has been extended twice because we were not ready to sell subscriptions yet, but now we are, and your service expires on 2026-10-13.

-Uwe-
 
   #3  

icardiag

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Mar 30, 2014
Messages
119
Reaction score
106
Location
Europe
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=113031
Now the question is, how to get over this restriction. Because all the work on the table with SFD protected units ain't possible anymore... Back to playing the cat & mouse games, episode 235 😇
From where the VIN code is pulled out on MQB platform? From the gateway or from the instrument cluster?
 
   #4  

stefdds

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Apr 13, 2015
Messages
5,220
Reaction score
3,890
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin USA
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=174556
Now the question is, how to get over this restriction.

VIN opens the potential for certain cheating of the system and we really do not wish to have a falling out with VW.

This is a public forum (to read) and that includes VAG. I think you are asking potentially damaging questions regarding Ross-Tech. Considering all the "hoops" RT has gone through (not to mention the financial cost), your table set-up is not a consideration.
 
   #5  

icardiag

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Mar 30, 2014
Messages
119
Reaction score
106
Location
Europe
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=113031
I strongly disagree, neither I want to cheat anything nor want to damage anybody. I just asked about a feature which was working before and I used it a lot before.
What's wrong asking about a feature I suddenly miss?? I'm registered, I'm verified, my ID is verified for SFD and I'm a paying customer so you are...
 
   #6  

Uwe

Benevolent Dictator
Administrator
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
63,319
Reaction score
43,663
Location
USA
VCDS Serial number
HC100001
I just asked about a feature which was working before and I used it a lot before.
I don't think SFD could ever have worked without something on your test stand ("table") from which VCDS was able to get a VIN.

From where the VIN code is pulled out on MQB platform?
It varies based where it can find one.

-Uwe-
 
   #7  

autocomsoft

VCDS Distributor
VCDS Distributor
Joined
Mar 17, 2014
Messages
584
Reaction score
723
Location
Czech Republic
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=56999
I'm registered, I'm verified, my ID is verified for SFD and I'm a paying customer so you are...

...they are a company that follows VW’s SFD rules; is this what you wanted to say?

I’m testing the SFD solution since its beginning, and I can say that VCDS was never able to handle SFD without a VIN. I think you were never able to use your SFD Beta access (if I understand correctly for FREE!) to unlock anything without a VIN.
 
   #8  

Sebastian

Ross-Tech Employee
Staff member
Ross-Tech Employee
Joined
Feb 13, 2014
Messages
3,854
Reaction score
4,621
Location
Magdeburg, Germany
VCDS Serial number
HN0-nnnnnn
Test bench usage is generally an edge case, for diagnostic functions in general and especially SFD - it is not considered a service purpose! The requirements are clear, read the Terms of Service.


5. User conduct obligations:

  • SFD functionality is to be used exclusively for requesting SFD tokens for vehicles that have been entrusted to the user's organization for diagnostic and service purposes.
  • Use of SFD for any purpose other than those stated here is prohibited. This applies, in particular, to purposes that are external to the user's organization.
  • SFD tokens provided via Ross-Tech's software are generated in relation to a specific person and their creation is logged. Any disclosure of user credentials or SFD tokens to third parties is prohibited.
  • Users must ensure that they are not breaching any applicable legal regulations and/or infringing any rights of third parties by using SFD.
  • Users must ensure that no security measures of the SFD process are bypassed.
  • Users must ensure that no equipment or applications are used in a manner that would disrupt Ross-Tech's or VWAG's servers or networks.
  • Confidential information and data (e.g. SFD tokens or login credentials) must not be disclosed to third parties, not even to other people within the user's organization.



8. Final provisions:

  • Ross-Tech reserves the right to revoke access to SFD Services for any user who violates these Terms of Service.
  • Ross-Tech reserves the right to make changes to these Terms of Use with reasonable notice to users who have current subscriptions.
  • Should any provision of these Terms of Use be determined to be void, invalid, unenforceable or illegal for whatever reason, such provision(s) shall be null and void; however the remaining provisions of this Agreement shall be unaffected thereby and will continue to be valid and enforceable.
  • These Terms are governed by the laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Any disputes shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
  • By creating an account for SFD Services or purchasing a subscription for SFD services from Ross-Tech, the user confirms that they agree to all of the above terms and provisions.
  • We cannot offer SFD Service to users in any country on the EU or US sanctions list for software. Examples include, but may not be limited to: Russia, Belarus, Syria, and North Korea.
 
   #9  

icardiag

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Mar 30, 2014
Messages
119
Reaction score
106
Location
Europe
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=113031
Regarding SFD in general - same problem with suddenly mandatory VIN code for SFD unlocking was introduced lately in every other 3rd party diagnostic tool besides VCDS (I won't name these here, surely you know). The wind blows from VW, as expected.

...they are a company that follows VW’s SFD rules; is this what you wanted to say?

I’m testing the SFD solution since its beginning, and I can say that VCDS was never able to handle SFD without a VIN. I think you were never able to use your SFD Beta access (if I understand correctly for FREE!) to unlock anything without a VIN.
I repeat again - I'm not blaming RossTech for anything!!! I just got curious about a feature which was working few weeks ago and suddenly is no longer working. This was the reason I posted the initial question. Thanks to Uwe for the explanation in first post; I just don't get the next responses of others, sorry.

Honzo, when you check your database of customers surely you'll find my license there. I spent thousands of Eur in your shop, some devices were bought under my personal name; some bought for the workshops I work for remotely. And regarding the SFD unlocking without required VIN code - do you remember there was a section on your website exclusively for your customers providing a SFD unlocker few months ago? It was enough to post the challenge and the response was generated by your website. Simple copy & paste and magic, SFD unlocked. Suddenly one day if got removed from your website without any information or explanation...

Test bench usage is generally an edge case, for diagnostic functions in general and especially SFD - it is not considered a service purpose! The requirements are clear, read the Terms of Service.
Sorry Sebastian, I really don't understand how I'm in the conflict with Terms of Use. I'm an independent workshop, I have certificates, GRP and GEKO access, I follow the rules. A car comes in with a faulty navigation. I need to unlock SFD for diagnostic and service purposes. What's the difference when I unlock the SFD when the unit is still in the car or when it's on the table? It's the same broken unit with same serial number. I'm not breaching any legal regulation, not infringing anybody's rights; I just want to fix a broken device. So please explain why my approach it's not considered a service purpose. I tried to read the Terms of use several times, maybe my English is not so good, but I haven't found any single point where I'm in conflict with.

I didn't and don't want to upset anybody, it's not my intention. But I feel falsely accused and in the end threatened with legal actions?? Please explain clearly why I'm wrong and I won't be wrong anymore, that's all.
 
   #10  

Uwe

Benevolent Dictator
Administrator
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
63,319
Reaction score
43,663
Location
USA
VCDS Serial number
HC100001
I just got curious about a feature which was working few weeks ago and suddenly is no longer working.
Again, VCDS has always required a VIN for on-line SFD, since the very first Beta version that supported on-line SFD. Moreover the current Release version of VCDS (26.9.0) was published on the last days of August. Check the time stamp for the digital signature on the VCDS.exe file. In my view that is longer than "a few weeks".

Is it possible you were thinking that what worked previously was version 26.3 or earlier with off-line tokens?

I feel falsely accused and in the end threatened with legal actions??
We're not accusing you of anything. It's just that your questions make us a bit uncomfortable. We invested a tremendous amount of time and money to get where we are with SFD, and we seriously do not want to risk damaging our relationship with VW.

-Uwe-
 
   #12  

stefdds

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Apr 13, 2015
Messages
5,220
Reaction score
3,890
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin USA
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=174556
Please explain clearly why I'm wrong and I won't be wrong anymore, that's all.
As I mentioned in my post above, your asking questions (which is fine) , but you are using phrases like "getting around restrictions" ! That is a red flag! Especially if one isn't fluent in English ; think like VAG is reading these posts. How would they interpret that question!

There is a fine line between curiousity and tinkering and Hacking. (ie working around a function meant to verify a certain step).

We all know what the "spirit of the rules" of SFD is ; they are clearly stated.

Reminds me of the Motorsports rules and how creative builders would cercumvent the rules in a creative way. Well , says the builder, it doesn't say you can't do that.......

Clearly, just because it isn't stated, doesn't mean it is acceptable . Hence the "spirit" of SFD terms of use and it is quite obvious they want to know exactly what a user is doing with VAG software.

Whatever it was you were doing and that it does not work now is beside the point, (I don't speak for RT) IMO, the forum can't answer or does not want any part of those types of questions as they could easily be misinterpreted as breaching SFD VAG terms of use.
 
   #13  

Sebastian

Ross-Tech Employee
Staff member
Ross-Tech Employee
Joined
Feb 13, 2014
Messages
3,854
Reaction score
4,621
Location
Magdeburg, Germany
VCDS Serial number
HN0-nnnnnn
Sorry Sebastian, I really don't understand how I'm in the conflict with Terms of Use.

Please re-read them and compare what you are doing to regular service work. What you describe is simply out of scope of normal service operations which for example an authorized service center would perform. Nobody there will ever be instructed to put a possibly broken headunit on a bench for testing. Any next level process beyond regular dealer level repairs, would have a proper bench setup which would be compliant with these requirements. You seem to try to wiggle around in between, which is why this doesn't work. So don't do it the way you do it now, or do it properly.

Let's not waste any more time on this. Everything has been said here. If you don't like the situation, I think you may want to look for another tool manufacturer who is willing to circumvent VW's requirements. We are not.
 
   #14  

icardiag

Verified VCDS User
Verified
Joined
Mar 30, 2014
Messages
119
Reaction score
106
Location
Europe
VCDS Serial number
C?ID=113031
Let's not waste any more time on this. Everything has been said here. If you don't like the situation, I think you may want to look for another tool manufacturer who is willing to circumvent VW's requirements. We are not.
Agreed, I will use another tool manufacturer for SFD. And not because there's somebody who is willing to circumvent VW's requirements (because all providers have to meet the recent requirements of VW), but because of your company's attitude.
I feel really sorry that after a lot of years being a happy customer I feel treated like a scum bag just because I asked why I cannot edit the VIN code. Instead of a simple explanation "because it's the requirement of VW and we cannot go against it" I received a public ashaming how bad I'm and how I want to damage your company...

I'm still waiting for the reply of @autocomsoft (who is your official sales representative in Czech Republic!), how it was possible they provided a free SFD generator for their customers not so long time ago. Surely that was OK and I'm the bad guy who pointed that out.
 
   #15  

Sebastian

Ross-Tech Employee
Staff member
Ross-Tech Employee
Joined
Feb 13, 2014
Messages
3,854
Reaction score
4,621
Location
Magdeburg, Germany
VCDS Serial number
HN0-nnnnnn
Sigh... Let's sum this up, shall we?

In #2 Uwe gave you the simple explanation you asked for. In #3 you asked how to circumvent that, to which you got replies which you didn't like. Now you call us out for having an attitude, after several folks here took the time to point you towards answers and background information to your question. You did not get a public shaming, so please frame it as such. Nobody made you "the bad guy", you took that entirely upon yourself after you didn't like the answers you received.

As I wrote earlier, no service work would ever require a shop to put modules on a bench. That's the gist of it. You want to do things not by the book, which is your right, but please don't blame us for not playing that game with you.
 
   #16  

Uwe

Benevolent Dictator
Administrator
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
63,319
Reaction score
43,663
Location
USA
VCDS Serial number
HC100001
all providers have to meet the recent requirements of VW
I guarantee you that no "gray market" source of SFD tokens has ever met VW's requirements.

I feel treated like a scum bag just because I asked why I cannot edit the VIN code.
And I explained why in post #2. I did not treat you like a scumbag. You asked. I answer why. I did not suggest that you were doing anything nefarious, I just pointed out that having this ability could be used for nefarious purposes and that's why we don't allow it.

Instead of a simple explanation "because it's the requirement of VW and we cannot go against it"
It is not an explicit requirement from VW. However, we do have to send a VIN to VW's server every time we request an SFD token. VW knows what modules belong in what cars, and we do not wish to be "flagged" by VW when some of our customers request tokens for modules that don't belong with the VIN being sent with their requests.

I'm still waiting for the reply of @autocomsoft (who is your official sales representative in Czech Republic!), how it was possible they provided a free SFD generator for their customers not so long time ago. Surely that was OK
Technically, it was not OK. I'm not sure where they got those tokens, but it was never OK for someone who had an account able to generate off-line tokens to give them to anyone else. Yes, I know some of our distributors were doing that, but it was not Ross-Tech doing that. We were always quite clear about this: VCDS could be used to work with off-line tokens but we could not provide such tokens.

-Uwe-
 
Back
Top